Saturday, January 16, 2021

More Dead Than Alive

Selig Ährenfeld, his name later anglicized to Henry Arntfield, was the single German ancestor of the only fifty or so descendants who still bear this unusual surname in all of North America.  During his lifetime he would survive two catastrophic industrial accidents which would leave him severely disabled
for the last twenty-five years of his life. 

Our ancestor was born in Bützow in what is now Germany on March 3, 1831 to Jewish parents Ahraham Ährenfeld and Jette Mendel.  This was at a time when what would be future Germany was a still collection of various autonomous kingdoms, duchies, and states. Although all that would change with the 1871 unification of Germany, Selig’s birth city of Bützow was then part of the Duchy of Mecklenburg-Schwerin.

In 1852 at the age of twenty-one young Selig Ährenfeld decided to leave his homeland and immigrate to Canada.  His chosen destination was Ontario’s Waterloo County where there was already a large German presence in Berlin (later Kitchener) and surrounding towns.  In fact, by 1848 some nine thousand German immigrants had already arrived there. German immigration was high during the 1850s, a logical consequence of crop failures and famine across Europe in the preceding years.  Before German immigration finally peaked in 1854, many German states even provided assisted passage to ease population pressures and demands of social welfare.

Apart from wanting to better his lot in a new land, avoidance of military duty, although a supposition, may also have been a compelling reason for Selig’s decision to emigrate.  This conjecture is on account of an archival source, cited as the “commission”, mentioned by a German researcher in 2003.  One of its documents was said to refer to our ancestor, a merchant’s clerk “in very good health”, who was due to begin compulsory military service in the army of the Grand Duke of Mecklenburg in October of 1852.  Hamburg passenger list records show that Selig's emigration was on March 31, 1852, some five months before this military service was to begin. Opportunities in a new land as well as a desire to skip out on his imminent military service may thus have both been decisive factors in his decision to emigrate.

The result was that our 21-year-old ancestor sailed from Hamburg with, it appears, no other family members accompanying him.  His occupation on the manifest is given as "drechsler", a turner or one skilled in turning wood on a lathe, a skill which he would never put to use in Canada to earn a living. The ship he sailed on, The William Ash which flew an English flag, took him from Hamburg to New York City, likely via England. What may have been a reference to this departure was noted by local diarist Friedrich Seidel whose September of 1852 diary entry reads:

“A miller by the name of Wolf and the son and daughter of the “Jew” Abraham Ährenfeld emigrated to America.” 

(Although likely referring to Selig, the notation is confusing given his March departure for Canada months prior to the entry.  Equally problematic is the reference to a sister accompanying him, something unsupported by the passenger manifest for the William Ash. Despite these contradictions, the parentage provided is accurate. As well, since the only two other known sons of Abraham were by this time dead, by process of elimination the reference would clearly seem to be to Selig.)

Although the German ports of Hamburg and Bremen offered Quebec City passenger service via England, Seelig and most other immigrants preferred the direct and faster service to New York from Rostock. This was the route also chosen by Selig's future wife, Mary Schall.  At the age of twenty in 1852 with her mother and stepfather, she too in 1852 separately immigrated on a different another ship bound for Canada from Mecklenburg on a passage which likely bore similarities to that of Selig's.  Oral tradition passed on to her grandson Ray Arntfield was that her passage took three months and that many passengers, as was then usually the case, died en route.  She then “came as far as Buffalo by train and the rest of the way by ox-cart”. 

Selig and Mary Schall, although from the same general area of Germany, had not previously known each other before their separate arrivals in Canada within a short time of each other. Oral tradition from grandson Ray Arntfield was that: 

“Mary met another German boy who had come to Canada at almost the same time although they had not known one another in Germany”. 

A notation in the Arntfield family bible indicates that Selig married Mary within two months of her arrival in Canada.  Similarly, an unsourced obituary from a German language newspaper indicates that Henry arrived in Canada in 1852 and “soon after married Mary Schall”. 

The first Canadian census for which Selig, (now referred to as Henry) and Mary were present was that of 1861 when they are found living in Galt with their then four children.  The religion of all household members is erroneously listed as Roman Catholic.  By 1871 the family had settled in Hespeler where Henry had found employment in a local saw mill.  This census shows a now expanded family of eight children (two others are known to have died) living with Henry and Mary. On this census the family religion is correctly recorded, Henry shown as “Isralite” and Mary as Lutheran.  This census also records the fact that Henry had by this time lost his right arm.  This was due to an industrial accident sometime between 1861 and 1871.  Grandson Ray Arntfield records: 

“He was caught in the shafting and belting of a saw mill and belted aloft in the machinery until his one arm was torn out by the roots.” 

At the time of the 1881 census, although the family was still in Hespeler, the three oldest children and the fifth child, now adults, were out of the home.  The fourth child had by this time died.  There are now two new sons who are part of the household, one of whom, though listed as a son, is actually an illegitimate son of eldest daughter Caroline.  The family religion is now recorded as Evangelic Christian. 

Although no disabilities whatsoever are noted for Henry (the 1871 census having disclosed he was missing his right arm), it is likely that Henry, based on family oral tradition, had by this time already suffered his second industrial accident.  This, remarkably, had resulted in the loss of his left arm.  Grandson Ray Arntfield writes: 

“Years later [after the first accident] when he was foreman in a woollen mill he lost his balance and fell into a cutting machine which he was repairing and his remaining hand was caught in the knives and fed into the machine until his body clogged the works.  They found his body, more dead than alive and that was the day my father was born --- a six and half month boy --- grandmother’s eleventh and last.” 

The exact date of this second tragic accident can thus be pinpointed as April 27, 1872 since that was the day that Ray’s father Fred was born.  It was Ray’s separate recollection that Henry, it was said, that the accident occurred after Henry had been called back to the mill at night to repair the machine, and that, following the accident, he had, rather amazingly, not been taken to hospital but brought home “more dead than alive” following the incident. 

Although the subsequent 1881 census was silent on disabilities, the 1891 census does mention that Henry had lost both his arms.  Life was clearly not easy for Henry and Mary after his second accident.  Grandson Ray writes: 

“Strange to say, Grandfather survived and from then on. Grandmother had not only all the kids to raise, also the adopted ones, and also had to do everything for grandfather, dress and undress him, cut up his food, put it in his mouth, take him to the bathroom, and keep boarders to find a few bucks.  Needless to say it was a mighty poor existence they worked out but they lived like that for twenty-six years until after I was born.  Father had to leave school at ten years of age and go to work at the woollen mill at two dollars per week with twelve hour days.” 

Despite all, the family managed to survive on the income from the boarders taken in and from those adult children who were able to provide some financial support.  Although there was clearly not much work to be had for an armless labourer, Henry persevered.  An1878 directory for Hespeler lists a Hy “Ardfield” who was working as a pedlar; life as a pedlar without arms must have presented a host of challenges. Later directories record that Henry worked as a tobacconist.  One assumes, given his disabilities, that as a tobacconist Henry had to have help in the store or strongly rely on the assistance and honesty of customers helping out with the transacations.

Henry carried on in this fashion until his December 20, 1899 death of apparent heart problems.  Although later census records listed him as Protestant, at death his religion is once again recorded as Hebrew.  His entire estate consisted of five hundred and sixty-five dollars, mostly consisting of inventory in his tobacco store.  His wife Mary would go on to survive him for almost another eighteen years. 

Although Henry fathered eleven children, three would die as youngsters and three more as young adults.  It is only through three sons that the Arntfield name continues in North America to-day.  Henry’s grandson Ray  perhaps summed it up best when he described his numerous aunts and uncles as “short lived and rather harum-scarum”. 

Henry’s challenges in life, although perhaps due to a certain amount of carelessness on his part, also underscore the incredible inadequacy of safety standards in factories at the time.  Despite all, in an era without the remarkable prosthetics of to-day, Henry managed to cope with his daunting disabilities for almost three decades until his death.  His resilience serves as an example for us all. 

                                                                                                                                   David Arntfield 

                                                                                                                     

No comments:

Post a Comment